Law Offices of Charles D. Naylor

Expert legal representation for maritime workers and cruise ship passengers.

310-514-1200
  • Free Injury Hotlines
    • Cruise Injury Hotline
    • Longshore Injury Hotline
    • Seamen Injury Hotline
    • Shipyard Injury Hotline
  • Practice Areas
    • Maritime Personal Injury
    • Jones Act
    • Cruise Ship Injury
    • Commercial Fishing Injury
    • Longshore & Harbor Workers
    • Shipyard Accidents Attorney
    • Maritime Wrongful Death
    • Maritime Trucking Accidents
    • Boating Accidents
    • Catastrophic Injury
    • Death on the High Seas Act (DOHSA)
    • Defense Base Act
  • About Us
    • Charles D. Naylor
    • How We Work
  • Client Reviews
    • Verdicts & Settlements
    • Longshore Worker Wrongful Death Claim
    • Client Satisfaction Survey
  • Legal Resources
  • Videos
    • Injured At Work?
    • How To Choose The Best Doctor
    • What Is The Longshore Act?
    • Cruise Ship Injuries: Know Your Rights!
    • Naylor: Attorney of the Year Finalist
    • Defense Base Act
    • Commercial Fishing Accidents
    • What Is The Jones Act?
    • How To Document An Accident Scene At Work
  • Blog
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Jones Act / Jones Act Protects Maritime Workers – Jones Act Legal Cases

October 20, 2011 By naylorlaw

Jones Act Protects Maritime Workers – Jones Act Legal Cases

The Jones Act provides protection to maritime workers that are injured on the job so it is important for maritime workers to understand their rights. Below are two recent legal case examples:

Jury Rules in Favor of Ship Repairman who Suffered Serious Neck Injuries

Gilberto Villegas was working as a ship repairman for APM Terminals in the Port of Houston and suffered a serious neck injury. Mr. Villegas was unloading materials from his pickup truck at the Port of Houston’s Barbours Cut Terminal when his truck was rammed by a yard mule truck driven by an APM Terminals employee. The impact caused several injuries, the most severe of which led to neck surgery to alleviate pain from two herniated discs. The defendant, APM Terminals, tried to argue that the collision could not have caused such a serious injury because the yard mule truck was only going 1 or 2 miles per hour. They also stated that Villegas had complained about neck problems before the accident. They offered a settlement of $35,000 and the plaintiff rejected the offer. The Jones Act attorney representing Villegas successfully argued his claim in front of a jury. The jury awarded Villegas an award of $1.55 million, more than enough compensation to provide for his personal and medical needs for the rest of his life.

Court Rules Injured Iron Worker Qualifies under the Jones Act

Jacob Kinchen and his coworker Larry Abshire, both iron workers, were traveling to their job site. They were working on the construction of a bridge. At the end of a working day, as they were traveling back from the job site to shore, their boat collided with a survey tower. At the time of the accident, Kinchen was operating the boat. He was not a licensed captain. Both men claimed that they were seamen under the Jones Act, and were therefore entitled to file a claim under the Jones Act. Under the Jones Act, to qualify as a seaman, the worker should meet 3 criteria: the seaman should be assigned to a vessel or a fleet of vessels, the vessel should be in navigation, and the seaman should have a significant relationship with the vessel.

The two workers argued that they had a substantial relationship with the vessel because they contributed to the work of the vessel, and spent most of their time on the vessel. However, their employer, Boh Bros, claimed that the two were not Jones Act seamen, but longshoremen. Likewise, the two workers had been assigned to work on a bridge and not a specific vessel. Their duties resembled those of longshoremen and stevedores, and not those of seamen under the Jones Act. A court ruled that the iron worker qualifies as a seaman under the Jones Act. However, Abshire’s motion for partial summary judgment as to seaman status was denied.

If you have been injured in a maritime accident, contact a maritime lawyer who understands this area of the law. An experienced Jones Act attorney will help you receive fair compensation.

Filed Under: Jones Act, Longshore and Harbor Workers' Compensation Act

Get a
Free Case Review

Are You Injured?

  • Cruise Injury Hotline
  • Longshore Injury Hotline
  • Seamen Injury Hotline
  • Shipyard Injury Hotline

Know Your Rights

  • Injured At Work? Here’s What You Need to Know
  • How To Document An Accident Scene At Work
  • How To Choose The Best Doctor For Your Compensation Claim
  • Commercial Fishing Accidents: What You Should Know
  • Defense Base Act: Coverage, Benefits and Compensation
  • What Is The Jones Act?
  • What Is The Longshore And Harbor Workers’ Compensation Act?
  • Cruise Ship Injuries And Your Rights
  • Charles D. Naylor Named Consumer Attorney of the Year Finalist
Best Lawyers Lawyer of the Year Charles D. Naylor Certified Specialist_Charles D. Naylor
Workers Injury Law and Advocacy Group_Charles D. Naylor American Association for Justice_Charles D Naylor

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Connect

Copyright © 2023 · NaylorLaw.com. All Rights Reserved. · Privacy Policy · Disclaimer · Sitemap · Call Us Toll-Free: 888-440-5829 · Local: 310-514-1200 ·
Law Offices of Charles D. Naylor · 11 Golden Shore, Suite 350, Long Beach, CA 90802