Law Offices of Charles D. Naylor

Expert legal representation for maritime workers and cruise ship passengers.

310-514-1200
  • Free Injury Hotlines
    • Cruise Injury Hotline
    • Longshore Injury Hotline
    • Seamen Injury Hotline
    • Shipyard Injury Hotline
  • Practice Areas
    • Maritime Personal Injury
    • Jones Act
    • Cruise Ship Injury
    • Commercial Fishing Injury
    • Longshore & Harbor Workers
    • Shipyard Accidents Attorney
    • Maritime Wrongful Death
    • Maritime Trucking Accidents
    • Boating Accidents
    • Catastrophic Injury
    • Death on the High Seas Act (DOHSA)
    • Defense Base Act
  • About Us
    • Charles D. Naylor
    • How We Work
  • Client Reviews
    • Verdicts & Settlements
    • Longshore Worker Wrongful Death Claim
    • Client Satisfaction Survey
  • Legal Resources
  • Videos
    • Injured At Work?
    • How To Choose The Best Doctor
    • What Is The Longshore Act?
    • Cruise Ship Injuries: Know Your Rights!
    • Naylor: Attorney of the Year Finalist
    • Defense Base Act
    • Commercial Fishing Accidents
    • What Is The Jones Act?
    • How To Document An Accident Scene At Work
  • Blog
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Jones Act / Negligence and Unseaworthiness Illustrated on Deadliest Catch

June 27, 2011 By naylorlaw

Negligence and Unseaworthiness Illustrated on Deadliest Catch

Under the Jones Act, a seaman has the right to sue his employer for negligence, and/or the vessel and its owner if he can prove an injury was the result of ‘Negligence’ OR ‘Unseaworthiness.’ The difference between these two theories of liability, and what they mean, is one of the least understood concepts in maritime injury law. An incident on a recent episode of The Deadliest Catch, however, illustrates the two concepts.

WATCH CLIP BELOW

About Negligence
A seaman’s employer has a legal duty to use “reasonable care under the circumstances” to avoid causing him or her injury. An employer (or vessel officer or crew member) does something that a reasonably careful person would not do, or fails to do something that which a reasonably careful person would do is negligent.

About Unseaworthiness
Unseaworthiness is different. It flows from the vessel owners “warranty” to provide it’s seamen with a seaworthy vessel. In other words, with a vessel and its crew are reasonably “fit”. If the vessel or any of it’s equipment has a dangerous or defective condition; or if working conditions on the vessel leave the crew exhausted an “unfit” to safely perform their duties the vessel is said to be “unseaworthy”.

Deadliest Catch
In the Deadliest Catch episode, cameras caught a 26 year old crew member asleep at the wheel in crowded seas, after a 14 day “grind” of crab fishing in the Bearing Sea. The crew member’s falling asleep at the wheel was clearly negligent in that a reasonably careful crew member wouldn’t do so; unless he was so exhausted from 14 days and nights of fishing that no one could be expected to stay awake. In that were the case, working conditions on the boat could be said to have made the crew member “unfit” for his assigned duty of standing wheel watch and the vessel would be considered “unseaworthy”.

Watch a clip of the episode below to decide for yourself whether the crew member was negligent, the vessel was unseaworthy or perhaps both could be said to apply.

Filed Under: Jones Act, Maritime

Get a
Free Case Review

Are You Injured?

  • Cruise Injury Hotline
  • Longshore Injury Hotline
  • Seamen Injury Hotline
  • Shipyard Injury Hotline

Know Your Rights

  • Injured At Work? Here’s What You Need to Know
  • How To Document An Accident Scene At Work
  • How To Choose The Best Doctor For Your Compensation Claim
  • Commercial Fishing Accidents: What You Should Know
  • Defense Base Act: Coverage, Benefits and Compensation
  • What Is The Jones Act?
  • What Is The Longshore And Harbor Workers’ Compensation Act?
  • Cruise Ship Injuries And Your Rights
  • Charles D. Naylor Named Consumer Attorney of the Year Finalist
Best Lawyers Lawyer of the Year Charles D. Naylor Certified Specialist_Charles D. Naylor
Workers Injury Law and Advocacy Group_Charles D. Naylor American Association for Justice_Charles D Naylor

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Connect

Copyright © 2023 · NaylorLaw.com. All Rights Reserved. · Privacy Policy · Disclaimer · Sitemap · Call Us Toll-Free: 888-440-5829 · Local: 310-514-1200 ·
Law Offices of Charles D. Naylor · 11 Golden Shore, Suite 350, Long Beach, CA 90802